It has happened again......

It was not so had to be? :scratch2:


atleast to have 150hp or + xx intel....



The only thing I can say is that I do not regret having stopped depositing!!!

so basically exclude people that have little activity or that are newer to eu (low skilled).

sounds like a great model to run a game :thumbup:

there will be something new to whine about next week no worries :D

kosmos
 
Going by their tracker, this is a joke, and why EU is so poor and should have a slapped bottom. Although as i do not know them, i do not know how much they have put in or what skills, what they have been up to i guess ill have to say gratz.
 
You're obviously new here. Star is the most skilled avatar in game and has had many very nice loots. Trading isk not at all how you explain him.

think Joda might still be more skilled then star

and Star started out trading, well atleast he is claiming that.
he wouldnt allow himself to hunt shoot other people when he didnt profit trading when he started out.
i just tried to explain how he started out with 45$ depo.
 
You're obviously new here. Star is the most skilled avatar in game and has had many very nice loots. Trading isk not at all how you explain him.
You're obviously new here. Star traded to begin with, gaining many skills via the profit he made for trading.
 
Lol, this doesn't happen "daily", once a month at best since the big whining post about this was only updated once a month. In fact, it happens so infrequently when I saw it I knew there would be a post here. Maybe X% of new players wouldn't quit when they get a big loot if the forum didn't make it a point to hunt them down and bitch them out? This forum has really turned into old players trashing everyone new because they don't "deserve" good loot, and trying to make sure new planets don't get anything good that will compete with all the gear the old players that deserve everything already have.
 
think Joda might still be more skilled then star

and Star started out trading, well atleast he is claiming that.
he wouldnt allow himself to hunt shoot other people when he didnt profit trading when he started out.
i just tried to explain how he started out with 45$ depo.

urban legend... i know for sure
 
Lol, this doesn't happen "daily", once a month at best since the big whining post about this was only updated once a month. In fact, it happens so infrequently when I saw it I knew there would be a post here. Maybe X% of new players wouldn't quit when they get a big loot if the forum didn't make it a point to hunt them down and bitch them out? This forum has really turned into old players trashing everyone new because they don't "deserve" good loot, and trying to make sure new planets don't get anything good that will compete with all the gear the old players that deserve everything already have.

no,you are wrong there....just check for yourself whenever you see an uber from an name you dont know....almost all the times their uber equals their total loot..
and youll be amazed to find out it happens almost on an daily basis
 
Yes actually i am.

Same shit made up facts as most of these threads, if that is the case then you basically had the same chance when we were all new didnt we? we just blew it obviously, and why not leave and return then if the chances are greater?

Also this 90% of noobs who hit it big leave and withdraw, lead me to that gem of a fact would you? or is it just made up or taken from the last one of these threads where that person made it up and now its a fact?

Actually no, I didn't have the same chance when I was new, because the system was totally different them. Big HoFs on noob mobs did not exist. Loots over 1k on any mob were rare. A 5k Daikiba Young was impossible.

My observations are based on personal experience during the last 5 years in EU. And no, 90% is obviously not an exact figure.

My frustration on this issue isn't even really about loot, it's about the fact that it's a terrible retention strategy. I'm not complaining about not getting the loot* - I don't mine so it was never going to be me getting it anyway. I'm just concerned that loots like this one are more likely to reduce the player base than increase it.

Still the usual suspects who fail to see this (or any other) issue in any depth will just call me a whiner (probably after calling me a fanboi last week) and go on living in their black-and-white world.

* I would like some loot though please thank you
 
Opinion based on observation/personal opinion holds no water with me. People observe things that upset them a lot easier than things that don't.

Opinion based on numbers and data please people! :)
 
Lol, this doesn't happen "daily", once a month at best since the big whining post about this was only updated once a month. In fact, it happens so infrequently when I saw it I knew there would be a post here. Maybe X% of new players wouldn't quit when they get a big loot if the forum didn't make it a point to hunt them down and bitch them out? This forum has really turned into old players trashing everyone new because they don't "deserve" good loot, and trying to make sure new planets don't get anything good that will compete with all the gear the old players that deserve everything already have.

like i said in earlyer post,this happens daily...and so it just happened again today !!!

http://www.entropiatracker.com/player.asp?mode=viewPlayer&PlayerID=158598

for those that cannot log into tracker...player hit argo young of 10.066
and total loot in whole eu-career is tadaaaaaaaaa.......;...10.313

every effing day this happens
 
I'm just concerned that loots like this one are more likely to reduce the player base than increase it.

It seems that nobody can see it!


And do we realy need to tell that it is a system fault and nothing to point to the player... (assuming that he does not have any connection with the MA)
 
It seems that nobody can see it!


And do we realy need to tell that it is a system fault and nothing to point to the player... (assuming that he does not have any connection with the MA)

now sow the seed he is something to do with MA :) Paranoia
 
How many of those newb accounts are created by the help of a
experienced player?

As I have mentioned earlier, learn the system, ask a friend to join,
play with that friends account (he/she log in, you play) get the
prof stand bonus, and then stop playing with that account.
Move the profit to your own account.
Ask another friend and... the circus has began. ;)

To be a bit more serious: the problem with a system where you
know that it gonna take years to even be able to loot good,
has not much of a future, since interest will most likely be at
a minimum.
A system where you as a player has played for years, spent a
s***load of peds, doing stuff both "right" and "wrong", and still
haven't got a loot over 1-3k, don't have much of future either,
since one day the system is yesterday news, and they must
trust on the addicted players.
To find a balance, where everyone has a decent chance to
loot good must be extremly hard, since if it is too easy to get
it, the system might be judged as gambling.
No matter what direction they head, there will always be
something that gonna create problems.
 
Like in all other gambling activities, there's a lot of begginers luck... It seems to work perfectly for other models, to increase addiction... If it is indeed a marketing strategy, it would only help to increase my belief that most of us play EU like a casino and that it is what the service provider wants... Even if the system can be played in a much more controled way (and it can).

All in all, for some to win big (THEM), some need to loose big (US) ;)

Is it really a strategy? I dont want to believe so, but it most certainly looks like so. But in reallity I think its all about luck. Period. That's what I love about EU... And God, that's what i HATE about it... :\
 
You shoot something, you drop a bomb, you click a crafting machine you have a chance to do the same why should it be any different for anyone? If i knew i didn't have any chance of getting a big one at anytime i wouldn't even start playing.
This. Also, if having more skills alone gave players a better chance of getting a HoF, MindArk's profits would dwindle (and perhaps turn negative). You have to remember MA is a business. That wouldn't be a very smart business move, now would it?
 
This. Also, if having more skills alone gave players a better chance of getting a HoF, MindArk's profits would dwindle (and perhaps turn negative). You have to remember MA is a business. That wouldn't be a very smart business move, now would it?

if this is the way it is then it truly is a casino..no doubt about it in my mind
 
if this is the way it is then it truly is a casino..no doubt about it in my mind
And anyone who thinks it isn't is kidding themselves.
 
how it is just possible that first glob in eu is a 1200 ped daikiba
lol
 
It's just like a casino, people should stop bitching about this stuff. If you really think new players have more luck MAKE A NEW AVATAR AND SHUT UP! Just an idea.
 
Hi,

how funny!



Cool. Lets have a look at the picture:

  1. We see a tracker record of a player. The first entry is from July 03, 210, 1155 PED, a HoF.
  2. We don't see more. Is it a record with a limited time span (from July 210 and newer), is this possible at all in the tracker? Dunno. Is this an avatar that had to change his name due to some unknown reason and was playing quite long before? Dunno. Is this an avatar that had initially set his tracker thingy to "hide me" and has changed then? Dunno.
    All I see is that his hunting is similar to mine, when I feel lucky. And I started 2005.
  3. Let's just assume that this guy started sometimes before July 2010, due to no other information available.
  4. He started with a quite nice loot (no idea how many critters he had to kill before, it took me nearly 2 years to get my first hunting global, and other ppl here are reporting even nastier times).
  5. Withdrawing it would have given him a nice profit, enough to fetch Mrs. Schneider to a quite impressive diner. He did not. Poor Mrs. Schneider ...
  6. Instead we see a quite global-less phase during late 2010, and in Jan 2011. Those poor phases are all but unknown to each of us, right?
  7. This guy comes back to the tracker in Feb '11, and globals on very different mobs then before. Obviously the 1155 PED from his initial HoF wasn't by far enough to gear up sufficiently & skill up meanwhile, so he must have deposited.
  8. If he didn't pause for some months, additional deposits would be required to pay the skilling from Aug '10 to Feb '11.
  9. Anyway, if he actually was a nOOb in July '10, he must have beefed up his HoF money with quite some deposits to advance in a way that is clearly shown by the tracker data.
  10. And now this guy scored big. After at least 9 months of participation, maybe even ways more. And the mob is whining, as usually.
  11. Btw., Mr. Schneider has made some crafting globals, 662 PED. Why don't we see 'em in both pictures? Just cut off? Why? Did the date of those not fit the picture? Dunno. Shady.

In short:

We have a nOOb (maybe, not sure), that started with a quite nice HoF. What is predicted for such a case?

90% of the people who get these noob-loots withdraw all the PEDs and don't come back.
Yes, exactly, Mr. Schneider must have been one of the remaining 10%, for sure. But what sense makes such a statement like this here then, when he's among the most few ones actually to be in these 10% anyways (btw, I doubt the 10% from my own, and my Soc mates experience, any data available to proof this crude assumption? Plz share with us!)?
Just doesn't make any sense, is just another rant, another whining, another attack to the lucky one.
Do we really need such in the forum?
(And I'm not attacking the poster of the above quote - what he wrote is common sense as we see in many posts)

The picts clearly show the exact opposite of what is claimed here. This nOOb-or-not did not withdraw after an initial-or-not HoF. This nOOb-or-not came back to the tracker a few months later with a substantial rise in the difficulty of the hunted mobs, that wouldn't be possible with his initial-or-not HoF - heavy skilling and/ or continuous depositing is to assume.

Mr. Schneider then scored big. Gratz, Mr. Schneider! You have earned it!
I had preferred if it had been me that received that 60K Igni, but I'm not jealous about - the next one might be mine. Use it wisely, Mr. Schneider, feel hugged in congratulations, and keep ground contact! You'll be doing well then!


But I'm sad about the greedy, whining attitude in this forum when it comes to loot.
Whenever someone but you yourself is lucky it's a reason to start a revolt-in-a-box? Over and over using such hand-made argumentations that are clearly most far-fetched for anybody having more IQ but shoe size? Your not ashamed doing such?

Let's have a look at it:

  1. Jane 'ThenOOb' Smith scores big in her first year, 50K PED. Extremely rarely such comes in the try-out/ sweating phase, the vast majority of participants receiving even a small global will undeniably be depositors. Too few "spins of the wheel" possible just from selling sweat. But, for sure, such may have occurred, a few times, during the PE/ EU life time, just as a unavoidable result of a random loot generation. And then blown up beyond all proportion using the well known mechanics of legend building and urban myths.

    No matter, Jane 'ThenOOb' Smith scored big now. Quite soon. Wouldn't she freak out, wouldn't she decide that this is the best game ever, wouldn't she spent all the won money for going for the next, maybe even bigger HoF? Or for an ATH, even?

    She just had learned that such is possible. Would she really withdraw, stop playing and waste her chance for another, maybe even bigger, "lucky strike", in the euphoria any big loot gives?

    No doubt, chances that Jane 'ThenOOb' Smith will withdraw are very low.
    .
  2. Now let's have a look at Joe 'RandomUber' RiffRaff, that just scored 50K PED, too. It's not this much money for him, since his gear alone coasted a multiple of this, not even to mention the skills he ate. Maybe this HoF doubled the value of his PED card?

    For Joe it would make sense to withdraw. It's no big money for him, he's used to receive big loots every day, mining with high amps, and hunting high stake mobs all day long. Due to the game mechanics he'd get ways more MU compared to Jane anyways, and these 50K would just be seen as a "present with an invitation to withdraw".

    Joe 'RandomUber' RiffRaff will withdraw it, for sure.

The theory of nOObs withdrawing quickly, and Ubers reinvesting, is IMHO just BS. It's exactly the other way around, IMHO.


This tracker stuff is from hell, IMHO.
It's mostly used for witch hunts, rants, bitching, slurring, belittling, attacking and expelling participants that had the luck the greedy moron didn't have.

As such they are a clear violence of quite a lot of chapters in the different EULA's and related documents, IMHO. Not even to talk of the grabbing of data meant to be seen in a certain program (EU) only, using automated 3rd party software, which is again the different EULA's and related documents, IMHO.

Opt-out, as some trackers offer, isn't a way. Find all trackers that are tracking you, using illegal 3rd party automated software to OCR the in game chat, to opt out - have fun! ...

Trackers would be acceptable when:

  • MA would provide a basic source itself, as a feed in any approbate way.
    .
  • And the participants would have the game option to chose like "show my name in trackers" or "show 'An Avatar' instead of my name in trackers", in the client loader. Team creation should have a check mark for this, too. Only "show team name" or show "A team"
    .
  • Any Trackers then would have a reliable source, and wouldn't need to handle personal data security issues of their own, taking quite a risk to be sued for high sums, and wouldn't need to use illegal 3rd party software to read the chat.

Never forget - these tracker data are not reliable. Not just only one friend of mine swears that the globals of several months, or random globals have vanished, or have been missed. Participants can "opt-out". Mistakes can happen.

I offer my avatar: "Xandra 'Madmaiden' Xandottir"
Analyze me using tracker data, tell me what you are thinking of me. Tell me what you found out using the tracker data.

No results? This would be what I expect. Any links of my data welcome. And any explanation.

For me, the trackers suck. Not only that they're at the very edge of legality, and infamously unreliably, they hurt my privacy. What I do with my avatar, Xandra, is up to MA, and to me. It's not meant to be grabbed by 3rd party bots.
Maybe one day, Tracker admins, I'd have the money? Maybe one day somebody will sue you for distributing private data? In my country it's clearly a crime what you do. Enjoy your Ad income, meanwhile ...

I'll post a proposition about checking tracking soon, working on it. The current trackers are just unreliable, and maybe even illegal.

Have fun!
 
Trying to be fair:

We can't know whether the person in question has played a lot before ET started recording (and there were massive DB losses a while ago, as well as recording gaps)

And we can't know whether the person in question is maybe hunting in team a lot, or doing small stuff that just won't global (like basic filters on full quality, or hunting snables).


Having that said, i think the loot system as it is now completely SUCKS.

Rewarding completely new players makes older players just feel as if someone pissed in their cereals.
Rewarding players that were inactive for a longer period of time makes playing daily somewhat pointless.
Accumulating huge losses before the system pays something back makes the ATH tabe look neat, but in reality it scares people away - having a 1K loot after you lost 5K within 4 weeks just feels like they are making fun of you.


There, i did it, my first loot "whining" post (well, not really). :silly2:


I mean, why are people rewarded for being INACTIVE?
That's just pushing people out of the door, can a system design be more stupid?
 
A long time ago, I beleived that big loots was a payback for the losses you have made.

But,when a few-weeks old player gets a 60k HOF, it should make clear that it's a casino economy rather than something to keep old players ingame. (mining=spin of roulette wheel, mining with amps=placing more than one chip on a number). As is item drops (=if you weren't there when MA pressed the "drop" button; tough luck).

Until this guy shows up and tells his story, or someone who knows him will tell that he's been ingame 10+ years, been active (and not just had an inactive avatar) and finally got his "well deserved" ATH after years of losses, I will believe that this person is indeed a new player. (New as in just begun, not necessarily as "just created his avatar").

A wild guess is that this is a secondary account who is created by someone in the "medusa group" and made a deposit to be a member, thus triggering the "dynamics". But again, I'm waiting for his/her story.
 
Last edited:
To respond to some posts marking this as being posted as a whine thread, The reason I posted this is not to degrade the looter, by all means gratz to him/her. I posted this because (some people may disagree with this) but I believe that the system is biased towards newer players as a retention strategy. This has happened before but never on quite this large a scale. That is what prompted me to post this, the fact that the system (I believe) works this way.

As for my 2010 tracker history, I was on break :D
 
Rewarding players that were inactive for a longer period of time makes playing daily somewhat pointless.

Actually,although Im not sure how long a break you are talking,I took roughly a 1 year break and came back and my loot was the same as before(if not a little worse).
 
how it is just possible that first glob in eu is a 1200 ped daikiba
lol

it is possible.. happened to me.. but it was a cornundacauda old and it was 1162 peds.. after a week of hunting them around old camp phoenix.
 
When total noobs get big loots> people get upset
When all time Ubers get big loots> people get upset
Noobs find > they have too little changes against older players
Mid level players think > the old ubers had all the changes to get "the nice stuff" and cant loose anymore
Ubers think its not fair noobs get big loots.
.....and the circle is round again.

The only thing I personally think is stinking, is the fact that loot (getting big globals and hofs on regular basis) is avatar related. I am very sure of that. In my 8 years of playing I have seen and observed that way too often, and now with the LA events going on you can easily confirm that by participating in some of them where well known names compete too.

But in the end... Its a fun game, and the big carrot of that one time ATH will keep on sucking us in ;)
 
Most big loots go to ubers - logical, they hunt the biggest mobs, cycle the most peds, and likely deposit the most money.

Not all big loots go ubers - some even go to relative noobs, but one must consider how many noobs exist, how many mobs they kill, and how freaking rare these events are.

I think the system is designed to hand out occasional big loots that anyone might hit, and that these loots disguise the much simpler fact that, for the most part, we get back a percentage of what we lose while cycling our peds (deposits are really irrelevant) and even most big loots are well paid for.

As a player retention plan it may seem stupid, but as way a making a non-gambling platform look and feel like a casino, and hit all the powerful emotional triggers that casinos use to retain their players, it is smart indeed.

So to summarize, noobs have sheer numbers on there side, ubers have massive ped cycling on theirs, and mid level players chug along, also getting their occasional huge hits, too. It seems like a logical explanation of what we witness with only one assumption - the presence of "promotional" uber and mega loots along with all regular loots - including regular ATH's

As for digging through tracker and passing judgment (which does not seem to be OP's point, at least), it's kinda sad.

(I must note the meta assumption of "non-gambling", which many reject)
:beerchug:

Miles
 
Last edited:
Back
Top