First, what Immortal said, though I may disagree on the profit level of the whole thing. Selling something to someone who refuses to pay the bills doesn't strike me as an optimal situation.
Meanwhile
A somewhat different issue is that many didn't like the change because they perceived EF as independent and this forum as official, and resented their material being used on an official forum ... then proceeded to blame MA+ (the buyer) rather than 711 (the seller) - a reaction that has always seemed rather odd to me.
Are you kidding? 711 got tons of grief over that. Tons. And SDS (
not MA, get your facts straight on who the buyer was) got almost no grief over it at all, even though they were the ones who initiated the whole deal. 711 didn't go to SDS, it was the other way around. And since at that time it seemed that Calypso was indeed going to be separated from MA permanently, do you really think he should have refused?
As for how it is now, PCF and EF, yes I can see how it seems odd, but if you simply view this forum as what it's supposed to be (Planet Calypso-related) and EF = whole Universe, then it's easier to understand.
And yes, I know about the complaints about too many forums. Yes there's an element of truth. However, what's the alternative? One single forum for al planets? Controlled by who? Who gets front page news on VU day? What rules are used when one organization is more rigid then another? How do you properly sell the planets as separate games within the same Universe if only one forum is used?