The Ped Trap That are Instances (Rehashed Story)

atomicstorm

Slayer
Joined
Aug 21, 2013
Posts
9,008
Location
Blockchain
Avatar Name
MeLoveYou LongTime FiveDolla
Found some old data from doing tons of Aakas keys 9 years ago. I thought I would share, as this ped trap still exists - and it needs changed overall STILL. To credit Arkadia, in response, they split it into SOLO (by kill mob) and TEAM (same ped trap), but the fact that you will lose a fair share of your TT is not disclosed. This is bad planning and deceitful at the platform level.

This was a lot of work and effort as I ran tons of keys to farm arkoins for my first land area, so long ago. I don't have any regrets. I made many friends, sadly many of who are long gone now - from the game and in life.

OP Note: This is in Hunting Section because this applies to all instances in the game except for Solo Aakas, mob specific caves (like CD, Brood Cave, Bristle), or mob specific instances (Cyrene mob instances, Toulan prepay 1H instances)

The data below represents Aakas instances of old and am reposting the story/recap. The key points here are the TT losses - which are guaranteed and this was at a time of 1.0. It hasn't changed.

Unless you are after some specific markup, stay away from these instances.


Posted April 19th, 2014 (and later was purged likely from new LA owner):

The raw data - 243 KEYS

Definitions:

Consumables - Loot pills, nanos, TT value of keys, performance enhancing drugs
Damage - Damage reported by the instance
Kills - Kills reported by the instance
DPP - Damage per pec based on damage reported (no overkill) and no defensive costs
Effective DPP - Damage per pec based on damage reported (no overkill) with defensive costs

Disclaimers
  • Error margin for these results is between 2-3% due to the likelihood that exact decay on some runs may have not been properly captured.
  • Summary and observations are subjective but with fairly decent size data samples to suggest claims.

Raw Data Link

I couldn't post the data in this thread. So here is a link that should be available to all as read-only.

Total ped returned: 74714.02ped
Total ped cost: 96517.11ped
Total loss in key runs: -21,803.29ped
% Return: 77.4%

------------------------------

Loot Acquired:


  • Dune Rider Harness (M) x1
  • Dune Rider Harness (F) x1
  • Dune Rider Foot Guards (M) x1
  • Dune Rider Arm Guards (M) x1
  • Dune Rider Helmet (F) x1
  • Lokabhu Electrifier Sword x1
  • Shagadi Disintegration Sword x1
  • Empty Skill Implant x4
  • Golden Key Housing x2
  • Golden Key Outer Ring x7
  • Golden Key Barrels x15
  • Golden Key Bearings x46
  • Golden Key Cogs x13

Summary and observations

  • It is possible to profit in TT if you get a special chest roll. It occurs less than 5% of the time for no more than 200% of chest value. Whether you blitzed the run or did a full clear did not seem to effect this chance with the sample size.

  • The instances seem to be tuned to the expected markup of items unintentionally. Because it is very difficult, if not impossible, to have a return over 85% TT, it appears that Mindark or Planet Arkadia thought the markup of the items at the end would compensate. Since the markup has dropped on all items (golden key parts and items), it is a losing proposition to run these instances especially when coupled with the markup on keys.

  • Continuing from the upper bullets, clearing more mobs only increases the TT loss; however, the TT return % stays roughly the same between 75-82%. It appeared to be possible to increase the TT return % the further over 3dpp that you are. If you are not capable fo running an effective DPP setup > 3dpp, then it is to your interest to only blitz the keys. If you feel that you want to do full clears, hope you hit some HOFs crafting keys or take the chance of doing keys on condition to perhaps cut into the cost with markup on residues or high multipliers with high QR blueprints.

  • Using an SIB, non-maxed setup only lowers TT return. It is extremely discouraged to go into Aakas instances with weapons that are not maxed because the loot does not reward with loot swings/variance that one might expect with loot theories (or perhaps not a theory anymore) like Bond Theory. Furthermore, using skill mods and attachments only increased decay and loss and did nothing, at least moderately measurable, to increase TT return.

  • To make the instances fairly break even or profitable, Arkoin MU should be 150-175% or drop items with decent markup instead of low MU oils. Bottom line, the instances are a markup game with no chance to profit via the TT game in any fashion.

  • Rockets were the best time savers in regards to killing Rakta and Yarrijak. It also seemed to stem off loss of overkills for these mobs which is very easy to do. The general effect on each of these runs, including decay, was an increase in DPP due to crits.

  • Arkoins seem to be loot pool limited. After many runs of having arkoins drop very often, they stopped dropping. From a >95% drop rate to a < 10% drop rate extremely quickly and this continued for the next 2.5 months.

  • Arkoins, statistically even with the runners, drop most often in 1-4 keys in small batches. Arkoins drop in larger batches but infrequently or rarely in upper keys starting with Key 5-10. This is likely due to the number of possible items that could drop in each of the keys and growing increasing based on level.

  • Weapons seem to drop more often in 4-8 keys; however, even though this is known in the community, I believe that this is because these keys are run the most often.

  • Armor drops most frequently and perhaps is limited to Keys 8-10.

  • ESIs are the redeeming items for markup in 4-6 keys.

  • Running level 1-3 keys should only be done if going for certain low markup MU golden key parts, finishing missions, or accumulating small batches of arkoins.

  • Running level 4-6 keys can be decent for finishing defender missions, accumulating arkoins (roughly 25-50% chance), looting UL items, or obtaining high and rare markup golden key parts. Keys 4-6 seem to have the highest markup return in relation to key cost and risk.

  • The rewards for running key 7s are inconclusive other than golden key parts.

  • The rewards for running key 8-10s are best for trying to obtain armor pieces that are equivalent to Angel and Shadow but the risk of loss is high. The redeeming items for these keys are Spleen and Kidney oil that perhaps can keep your loss minimal.

  • More information is needed but I observed, perhaps biasedly, that there seemed to be three underlining rolls with loot: Number of items, the specific item that will drop, and the quantity of said item. Other than this is typical for most multiplayer games, armor dropped for me regardless if I did full clears or blitz'd. Armor and weapons dropped when there were more than 3 items in the return pool. When arkoins, weapons, and armor dropped, the TT return % was lowered to compensate even with a very high DPP. It broke the trend that DPP does effect TT return. This was recorded using a formula called reward roll (seed) that allowed me to see most runs were in a very tight range unless arkoins/armor dropped. In one case, an armor piece dropped that was near a rare item ATH and the TT% return became out of balance (very low).
 
Last edited:
OP Note: This is in Hunting Section because this applies to all instances in the game except for Solo Aakas, mob specific caves (like CD, Brood Cave, Bristle), or mob specific instances (Cyrene mob instances, Toulan prepay 1H instances)
Am I correct in thinking it applies to A.R.C. Offensive Event ? (the cyrene event we had with skill juices in loot with Mecha Lupine mobs)
 
Am I correct in thinking it applies to A.R.C. Offensive Event ? (the cyrene event we had with skill juices in loot with Mecha Lupine mobs)
No, this only applies to instances where you get no loot from the mobs and open a crate/chest at the end
 
Offtopic. But what was the return also in beacons ? Like 90% ? I didnt run many to have some data.
 
Not really off topic but to my knowledge it was 82-88%. I haven't really run instances in 2.0. I had enough instances in 1.0 to know to stay away from them.

Am I correct in thinking it applies to A.R.C. Offensive Event ? (the cyrene event we had with skill juices in loot with Mecha Lupine mobs)
No, but the mobs there were improperly loot balanced/TT balanced. I don't know what the story was there. We know that shrapnel has certain limitations. All shrapnel mobs really have no place on low-mid volume planets. They're gonna need to work on that for the next time they do that event.
 
seems like this would apply to the CUHOF instance on Toulan as well, no?
 
We know that shrapnel has certain limitations. All shrapnel mobs really have no place on low-mid volume planets. They're gonna need to work on that for the next time they do that event.

I think they plan to run it again this summer with some changes like teams allowed as well as solo, boss mobs etc. They haven't mentioned any changes with regard to shrapnel, at least not that I'm aware of.

What limitations does shrapnel have?
 
Not really off topic but to my knowledge it was 82-88%. I haven't really run instances in 2.0. I had enough instances in 1.0 to know to stay away from them.


No, but the mobs there were improperly loot balanced/TT balanced. I don't know what the story was there. We know that shrapnel has certain limitations. All shrapnel mobs really have no place on low-mid volume planets. They're gonna need to work on that for the next time they do that event.
I just made a suggestion on arkadia discord with the request to devs to have a look on it. Lately alot is happening with ark and changes are going in the right direction so there is a big chance that something will change and we get more arkadia stuff.
 
I just made a suggestion on arkadia discord with the request to devs to have a look on it. Lately alot is happening with ark and changes are going in the right direction so there is a big chance that something will change and we get more arkadia stuff.
For Arkadia, it would apply to their team instances and their underground vaults that people don't do anymore. If I was going to revamp anything, I would start with the vaults - and make them accessible by terminal.
 
I also did some extensive runs and kept logs, which i submitted to arkadia devs and via support.....(arkadia asked me to send them via support also....

I ran multiple instances and came up with even worse stats then you posted here, the volatility was insane and it was a guaranteed loss no matter what.

Arkadia is well aware these instances are worthless and robbing people who run them....and based off you reporting , myself and others....they dont care....
 
I also did some extensive runs and kept logs, which i submitted to arkadia devs and via support.....(arkadia asked me to send them via support also....

I ran multiple instances and came up with even worse stats then you posted here, the volatility was insane and it was a guaranteed loss no matter what.

Arkadia is well aware these instances are worthless and robbing people who run them....and based off you reporting , myself and others....they dont care....
It's not just Arkadia - it's any instance that gives a chest at the end.

Rocktropia used to be the worst of the instances because there were bugs that prevented you from completing the instance - and so the TT of the key was lost. They even made a business model around having special instances.

Arkadia crafters and LA owners years ago had a group chat. In that group chat, I had prompted the (then, but not now) CEO of Arkadia, David about the instances. He didn't care and when I also said the loot in the golden keys were bugged following their solo/team change, he scolded and dismissed me for the report.

They know and they are betting you don't know or care.
 
I remember entering some instances where you got a "This is a lucky instances with improved loot" dunno if i ever noticed getting that thou at the end. Same message appered in Moloch Depths at the beginning.
 
Did I ever tell you how much I hate instances? It's supposed to be a persistent world simulation! Geez.
 
I remember entering some instances where you got a "This is a lucky instances with improved loot" dunno if i ever noticed getting that thou at the end. Same message appered in Moloch Depths at the beginning.
This is a carry over from batsims that they never removed or fixed.
70% tt loss is pretty normal game wide.

If I cycles shrapnel and loot I loose almost 98% of tt value
This is false.
 
Back
Top