If the guard time is supposed to be for an hour, but due to server problems a lot of people are locked out (spending time at login prompt, not able to reclaim vehicles, not able to get good weapons from storage) then it's not a full 60 minute fight.
There was too much of issues for this event to be considered running normally as other landgrabs in the past.
Note that I don't say that, if this has been without server problems, you would have lost the fight. I sort of got an indicator of which side that would win when Star logged in. And, if it's as you said, 30 peopel were mid-air it ment pretty much everyone in your (top-level) society was there. 17 people were left in the "Revolt" society when I checked the soc term, and at time of battle I guess it would be core 30 people from each side. And from here, estimate average gears and skills.
As for your entire society crashed there, unless all opposing people were runnign their clients in some debug mode, it also ment most of the opposers also crashed. (I got CTDs about once each 30 minutes on Arkadia during oratan event later that evening so I got my fair share of CTDs. Difference was ofc that I was Able to log back in again after waiting that "already logged in".) As for people being 10 seconds from the claim, I hope they weren't hanging out at the "safe spot"...
Didn't I write it?
Though, thanks for your thoughts, it gives me an idea how you see the bigger Picture.