Q&A Answers (May 07)

Marco|SDS

Prowler
Joined
Feb 15, 2005
Posts
1,482
Location
Gothenburg, Sweden
Hello crew!

Here are the Balancing Manager's responses to the Q&A. Any questions that were unrelated to balancing were omitted. Also, rather than respond "I cannot comment on the inner workings of the dynamics of Entropia Universe", any other questions that required such a reply were also omitted in the responses.

Thanks to all who provided questions for this thread. A New Q&A will come later on, and with a faster time frame between Q:s and A:s.


Post 2
Are rare items expensive because they are rare or have they become rare drops because of inflation?
Submitted by Soundboy

It’s because of their rarity.


Post 5
What were the biggest/most surprising balancing mistakes ever made?
Submitted by Pirx Danford

When the loot during 10 seconds after a release contained 1000 times more shadow armor parts than there should have been.


Post 11
When am I going to get some decent loot or claims bigger than ample?
Submitted by dean

I actually don’t know and that’s a good thing.


Post 13
The question is would a hunter have the same profit with the same loot on different LA's with different taxes?
Submitted by Raffaele Meiers

On a land area with higher taxes the hunter pays higher taxes.


Post 14
Why do you not "raise the bar" with SIB tools and weapons that require skills higher than the current "maxed" skills (~10k average) to give ubers something to aim for instead of destroying the chances of anyone new becoming uber (without an uber bank account)?
Submitted by Doer

We are doing that.

Post 17
There are certain items that have disappeared completely from the game, or are stuck on old avatars not active anymore. I think it’s a shame that those items will be lost in history (and in some cases, all we have is pictures to know they existed). Not only talking about equipment, but rare clothing-pieces. We all know clothing doesn’t drop anymore so getting it back seems rather hopeless unless you plan to do something about it.
Do MindArk in any way plan for these items to have their "return" on Calypso?
Submitted by Skam

We have no plans to return these items.


Post 18
Sometimes fairly common types of loot stop dropping completely, like Fine wool a few weeks ago. Is this on purpose or by mistake?
Submitted by Darkaner

There is always a natural variation cycle in drop rates on all items.


Post 22
Is the promised MindForce update coming or have you given that up?
Submitted by nisse

It hasn’t been given up on. It will be done.


Post 26
Does EVERY one in Entropia have the same programmed or instilled "luck"?
Submitted by jak

Of course everybody has the same installation there is no such thing as luck.


Post 31
Why are rifles so plentiful and seemingly encouraged, with few options in melee weapons?
Submitted by Spud Striker

We are starting to introduce more now, with many more planned for.


Post 32
Was the almost 20k ped HOF of Rugaritz a regrettable mistake?
Submitted by strakkan

No, but very rare.


Post 33
Can we expect more L weapons to fill the incremental SIB equipment void soon?
submitted by The Nightbird

Yes.


Post 42
As the balancing manager how do you determine when you can release more Land Areas/Asteroids/Space Stations/etc without severely impacting existing owners and their profit?
Submitted by Vap0r

Time, statistics, and a pre-planned release strategy.


Post 45
Will there be unlimited (!) melee amps, or improvement of melee generally?
Submitted by Alice

Yes to both.


Post 48
Will you ever actually release a list (sort of a 'Heads Up!') in regards to HOW and possibly WHAT drops certain new items?
Submitted by Sunab Naverith

We have no such plans today.


Post 50
What is the effect of the new auction fees on the general market transaction balance?
Submitted by helena

No unnecessary transportation sales, no display entries in the auction, an overall growth of the use of the auction and finally a growth of the use of participant owned shops.


Post 52
What role do the commercial ads play with loots, ATH and HOFs?
Submitted by Haxtor moogle

They add money to the system by being watched.


Post 55
When will you update with something not only MA is gaining on?
submitted by SODERD

We have done, and do so with every release - sometimes small things, sometimes whole systems. To take some examples: sweating, land areas, participant shops, auction system, real world and participant commercial system, Event system.


Post 56
How many people are in the balancing department, what are their responsibilities and what is the process to balance a VU (loot changes, new features, etc.)?
Submitted by fluke

I cannot go into details here, but there is a group of more than five people involved in all balancing.


Post 62
Will there be any amps for faps in the near future?
Submitted by Omega

We have no plans today to introduce them.


Post 63
Why does MA make things better for crafters and worse for miners and hunters.
Submitted by bigdeal

We don’t, there are always ways to find opportunities in all systems.


Post 64
Can we expect to see more frequent events and story lines that actually have both a head and a tail?
Submitted by JackFree

Yes.


Post 69
What makes an item balanced?
Submitted by Dunn

Many parameters determine balance, here are some of them. An item is balanced when:
It fits the user’s skill interval and current state in EU, meaning that it is fun to use and lets you interact with fun and intriguing events or mobs.
It doesn’t cost too much to use and its owner knows it.
You cannot drain the system with it.
It can be found in the way it was meant and with the right frequency.
The owner knows it’s expensive to use, but its fun to use or it has an interesting and unique advantage.



Post 78
How many in game data points are you able to balance?
Submitted by Gazza

There are millions if you mean when items and rules are created. A lot fewer when the systems, items and Entropia are running. The goal is to sit beside the universe watching the nature of Entropia take its course.


Post 79
I believe that the return rate (the "cash/ped" that the users are getting from the system as loot) should be increased. Why shall I play this game and not play on a casino where the odds are much more for me to gain some money?
Submitted by Niovara

I agree, everything we do aims for a better return rate for the users, but must still pay for the systems and us at MindArk. I think you should participate in Entropia because it’s a virtual universe and nothing else.

Market prices are at work, services are up for trade, socializing and training pays off. Opportunities are there all the time for the observant and hard working participant and not just at the same place everyday.

The universe isn’t static and predictable instead it’s built on natural laws and the goals of the users in it and that’s what makes it intriguing and full of possibilities.



Post 80
As far as I know only CEO and balance-manager know exactly about and set the parameters of the loot-system.
Since this is the most important part of the whole RCE-game: Is some 3rd person/team checking their work or do they just proof each others work?
Submitted by Agnus Dei

There is a bigger team working with these questions today.


Post 87
We've heard the term "Balancing Manager" ad nauseum, but there's been no real description of what that position entails. Please describe exactly what you balance.
Submitted by AlphaGeek

Firstly, there is a whole team involved in balancing work. The team analyze every new system from when it’s only an idea to when you all are using it.

What will the system affect? What will it give and what will it take? What should the cost be to use the system and the items connected to it? Who will use the system, who are the real life users of system and who are the in world users? How will the system affect the performance of the hardware and the software platform and what will it cost to solve possible bottlenecks?

And of course the team continually analyze how a system works long after it has been released.



Post 93
Does MindArk have any plans of rekindling the past staples of our economic growth, or is their vision purely of advancing into the future?
Submitted by Stryker

We are constantly working with both new and old systems. It’s just a matter of time and the point of view of the beholder.


Post 94
Some time after VU with amp nerf has passed. Now what were impacts of it on "balance" (maybe reallocating part of loot from opalo users to high-lvl hunters etc.)?
Submitted by Denis

There is now a point in constructing, finding, selling and owning amplifiers other than just the best type. This has boosted the whole economy regarding amplifiers.


Post 99
Why do some mobs loot a large variety of items while other mobs loot only 1 or 2 items?
Submitted by Chilly

All creatures have different benefits and drawbacks.


Post 105
Is it balanced to make it better for low and high level players and worse for the mid-level?
Submitted by habanero

All users can find opportunities no matter what level they are at.


Post 112
Today my hit ability is for example 3.9/10, 6.1/10 on EP-10 and the same up to EP-50, shouldn't the hit ability be higher on low guns and get lower on high guns depending on your skills?
Submitted by Rapido

You have to use skill interval dependent tools to get what you ask for.


Post 113
Is MA's plan to keep going the actual process: Universe drain investor through big PR that deposit a lot of cash to buy "asset" and parasite gamer with tax and fee to use the new universe feature (examples: malls, CND, Land areas)?
Submitted by Etopia

We want to have many types of user groups. Investors with possibilities to enhance the experience of Entropia are one of those groups but certainly not the only one or even the biggest. Remember that they in many cases do important work with their areas and it’s voluntary to enter their areas.


Post 121
Rare Items/Ores and especially Blueprints in inactive accounts are a huge balancing problem, because they can be reactivated.
Limited Items avoid this problem.
But what will you do to balance the existing rare Blueprints (etc) in inactive accounts?
Submitted by schnups

The inactive accounts are eventually purged and the items go back to Entropia open market. All this is taken account for in the balancing.


Post 126
Are we all dealing with the same virtual world, insofar as odds/rules/chances?
Submitted by Amanita

Of course.


Post 127
Will Houses ever have the option of selling items when a player is off line like a shop without the need of a shopkeeper?
Submitted by TotalTwist

You need to have a shop or a shopkeeper.


Post 128
Is Land Grab no longer existent?
Submitted by Mercury

It definitely is existent and will return, in a different way though.


Post 136
When will respawn rate of mobs be fixed during events?
Since kinda hilarious to try to host nice events for community if there isn’t any mobs left after 5-15min of shooting in LA. No problem with Big mobs and 10 or 20 participants, but above 20 participants LA will be wiped clean.
submitted by Zap

The mobs will re-spawn faster after the next release.


Post 148
In a previous support case I asked if there will ever be any whip better than my Cobra ME. The reply was NEVER. So if there will never be any whip with more damage - how can the taming system work with bigger mobs?
Submitted by Sneaky B'stard

Of course there will be more whips that do more damage.


Post 158
The transferring of skills as it is now seems to be very confusing for most players. Will we see a system that is easier to manage, like just entering i want to fill a chip with 10 PED worth of skill x, then it shows how many of your skills that would take away and you press ok?
Submitted by Snakecharmer

No plans for that now.


Post 176
What is the prime motivation in your balancing?

To create a sustainable intriguing world with indisputable natural laws that can host a vast number of users and activities.


Post 192
I'm wondering if MA is going to introduce more mobs that use firearms as their
combat mode? There are currently 96 mobs in Entropia, of those only 5 are firearms.
Submitted by m0000

Yes.


Post 212
Whilst this isn't strictly speaking a balancing issue, it does have a relevant impact for crafters. The lack of knowledge of what these attachments (scopes and lasers) actually do quite possibly subdues the market for them thus having a direct impact on the cost of crafting such attachments for crafters. Can MindArk provide a little more clarity as to the function of laser sights and scopes?
submitted by Jimmy B

More information has been delivered to all items, we are just not ready with all items yet.


Post 218
Now that players will be able to upload content of their own in form of pictures, ads or videos, wouldn't it be cool to be able to upload your own musical compositions?
Submitted by Glyphan

Yes.


Post 221
Will there be more shops available at places like Genesis, Omegaton, Sakura?
Submitted by Violet

Yes.


Post 270
Are there any plans to introduce farms in the game, or farming licenses?
Submitted by Dusk

Yes.


Post 271
Will we one day have the ability to take one melee weapon in each hand?
Submitted by ufcfl

Yes.


Post 272
Does MA has an "inferior loot list" for avatars that have been annoying?
Submitted by Micheva

No.


Post 281
Will an item appear on market by re-looting it after it was TTed (used up)? Is the rule applicable to any kind of items?
Submitted by Auktuma

I’m not going to give details, but it works something like that.
 
Last edited:

kygon

Slayer
Joined
Feb 25, 2005
Posts
8,970
Society
...Asylum...
Avatar Name
Kygon Shr00m Infraction
some good responses :)
 

Level

Elite
Joined
Jul 27, 2005
Posts
3,026
Avatar Name
1
''Post 271
Will we one day have the ability to take one melee weapon in each hand?
Submitted by ufcfl

Yes.''

Wow, imagine 2 imp survivals 7 :p
 

Dunn

Stalker
Joined
Feb 2, 2006
Posts
1,859
Location
Bergen, Norway
Society
Novus Ordo Seclorum
Avatar Name
Duncan Dunn Idaho
Hmm, some intersting answers here :)
 

DarkFire

Forum Ninja
Joined
May 4, 2005
Posts
1,878
Location
Denmark
Society
Dark Brotherhood
Avatar Name
Fiery DarkFire Winter
I do apreciate the feedback from MA, but damn they're keeping their cards close ;)
 

Hrafninn

Coffee addict
Joined
Mar 9, 2006
Posts
1,426
Location
Sweden
Society
OldTimers
Avatar Name
Herr Hrafninn Hrafninn
Very interesting, got some answers for questions I've been wondering about ever since I first entered EU. However, some answers raised even more questions.

So, if an old inactive account is drained and items return to loot pool, do they return in loot as the same items or as crappy L items? I guess I'll have to wait until the next Q/A. :rolleyes:

Thank you very much, Marco and the rest of MA's staff for clearing out some of the many question marks!
 

Konve

Marauder
Joined
Feb 28, 2005
Posts
6,068
Avatar Name
David Konve Williams
Post 271
Will we one day have the ability to take one melee weapon in each hand?
Submitted by ufcfl

Yes.
Cool :yay:
 

TelM8

Guardian
Joined
May 11, 2006
Posts
220
They must have had a good laugh when we asked these questions.

Q: What's the colour of your under pants?
A: It's made from 100% cotton, give it a guess! Yah!

I love it!
 

Da Snake

Alpha
Joined
Dec 1, 2005
Posts
547
Society
Miner's Mafia
Avatar Name
Ssurak "da Snake" Gelid
Post 270
Are there any plans to introduce farms in the game, or farming licenses?
Submitted by Dusk

Yes.


This one sounds real cool. I would love to plant a farm outside my house!
 

chielsen

Supportscammer for hire
Joined
Nov 24, 2005
Posts
3,224
Society
Groene Draeck
Avatar Name
Jan Phoenix Lid
Post 55
When will you update with something not only MA is gaining on?
submitted by SODERD

We have done, and do so with every release - sometimes small things, sometimes whole systems. To take some examples: sweating, land areas, participant shops, auction system, real world and participant commercial system, Event system.
You mention a lot of things that only costs us players more money.
For instance, Event System. Why does it cost money to create them? If it were only to make sure no 'fake events' are being set up, why not add the fee to the price money of that event.

Soderd means gaining in a monetary way, you only describe feature which might add more fun, but all costs extra money.
So what he means, when will there be added something that profits the users but doesn't mean we have to pay for it.
Things like landgrab etc.
 

Violet

Elite
Joined
Jun 30, 2006
Posts
2,536
Location
England
Society
Freelancer
Avatar Name
Violet Vi Neomir
Post 221
Will there be more shops available at places like Genesis, Omegaton, Sakura?
Submitted by Violet

Yes.
Thank you for taking the time to answer! Thought my question might get lost in the waffle. Cant wait until the next Q&A so i can ask "Will there be more teleports available at places like Genesis, Omegaton, Sakura?"

Some other interesting answers in there also :)
 

711

Site Admin
Admin
Joined
Aug 31, 2006
Posts
5,280
Thanks to Marco and the balancing team for taking the time to conduct this Q&A. :wtg:
 

RazorFire

Prowler
Joined
May 16, 2006
Posts
1,073
Location
London, UK
Society
Dark Brotherhood
Avatar Name
RazorFire Gazman Thernwym
Some very interesting answers there, I look forward to the coming VUs :D
 

Witte

Marauder
Joined
May 21, 2005
Posts
5,713
Society
Delta Force Elite
Avatar Name
Vlugge Witte Harrie
Some nice and straight answers. Although many answers require a timeframe in order to have any meaning at all.
 

dolera

Old Alpha
Joined
Aug 25, 2006
Posts
863
i am very disappointed that there has not been answered a single question about the new loot system.

Questions like
- why it was introduced (was the old system bad? not at all)
- why they think it's fair that many lose 80% while some win 8000%
etc
dont really require answers from the 'cant comment' category :rolleyes:

Most of the answers given hardly give any new insight :(
 
Last edited:

Rookie

Guardian
Joined
May 20, 2006
Posts
310
Location
Scotland
Society
Vampire HQ
Avatar Name
Karak Rookie Inu
Farms...

Food ..... does this mean the dreaded food packs ???

Don't want to stop a hunt & go eat a 'Big Mac' :(

Rookie
 

Fin

Alpha
Joined
Nov 2, 2005
Posts
603
Location
England
Society
Federation of Free Wanderers
Avatar Name
Finbar Fin McCullouch
Congratulations Marco on a set of clear direct and informative answers. Appreciate it.
 

Sirhc

Elite
Joined
Feb 1, 2005
Posts
4,313
Location
Temple of the Dark parts of the Mind
Society
Freelancer
Avatar Name
Sirhc Xerogs Drakcah
Post 17
There are certain items that have disappeared completely from the game, or are stuck on old avatars not active anymore. I think it’s a shame that those items will be lost in history (and in some cases, all we have is pictures to know they existed). Not only talking about equipment, but rare clothing-pieces. We all know clothing doesn’t drop anymore so getting it back seems rather hopeless unless you plan to do something about it.
Do MindArk in any way plan for these items to have their "return" on Calypso?
Submitted by Skam

We have no plans to return these items.


So I gather from this response to Skam's question that all items are not lootable anymore, right :confused: or did this response warrant a more lengthy answer than once sentence?

Maybe I am reading Skam's question wrong but I took it as two parts one will items stuck on old avatars be returned and two will some of the old equipment, weapons, and clothing make a return (albeit rare) to loot.


Post 121
Rare Items/Ores and especially Blueprints in inactive accounts are a huge balancing problem, because they can be reactivated.
Limited Items avoid this problem.
But what will you do to balance the existing rare Blueprints (etc) in inactive accounts?
Submitted by schnups

The inactive accounts are eventually purged and the items go back to Entropia open market. All this is taken account for in the balancing.
Hmmm so this answers that inactive accounts are purged and items reintroduced. What if they have old clothing or Ancient weapons can we expect to see those too?

Does this answer to post 121 contradict post 17 and does this give us any clarification that "All items still show up in loot" as it has been stated on more than one occasion?

Maybe they had to omit pertinent answers on these questions so they did not give the MA "secret sauce" loot formula away but I for one would like to know what is what and hopefully I am not alone here.
 

Knakker

Dominant
Joined
Jun 5, 2006
Posts
362
Society
GloryHound Irregulars
Avatar Name
Harry Raptor Knakker
Post 5
What were the biggest/most surprising balancing mistakes ever made?
Submitted by Pirx Danford

When the loot during 10 seconds after a release contained 1000 times more shadow armor parts than there should have been.
I found this one pretty hilarious. Especially if I think about people tt-ing them. Same time-period maybe? :D
 

DeeDee

Prowler
Joined
Feb 23, 2007
Posts
1,229
Location
Sweden
Society
Entropia Pioneers
Avatar Name
Dee Dee Deranged
You mention a lot of things that only costs us players more money.
For instance, Event System. Why does it cost money to create them? If it were only to make sure no 'fake events' are being set up, why not add the fee to the price money of that event.

Soderd means gaining in a monetary way, you only describe feature which might add more fun, but all costs extra money.
So what he means, when will there be added something that profits the users but doesn't mean we have to pay for it.
Things like landgrab etc.
There is a difference between costing money and MA gaining money.
The question was about MA gaining.. and examples he provided the costs apparently don't go to MA but directly back to the "loot pool".
 

Marco|SDS

Prowler
Joined
Feb 15, 2005
Posts
1,482
Location
Gothenburg, Sweden
Hmmm so this answers that inactive accounts are purged and items reintroduced. What if they have old clothing or Ancient weapons can we expect to see those too?
Items considered obsolete (like old clothes found in the loot) will not be reintroduced.

And no, neither the Imp Mk2 nor Mod FAP is considered obsolete. Just very, very rare.
 

Kjetil

Stalker
Joined
Feb 22, 2005
Posts
1,595
Location
Norway
Society
Via Dolorosa
Avatar Name
Kjetil
Thx for the answers. This was a really good post.

/Kjetil :cool:
 

Recoda

Prowler
Joined
Jan 30, 2005
Posts
1,350
Location
Sweden
Avatar Name
Recoda
Thanks a lot for posting this Q/A. It was for sure worth waiting for. I'll be looking forward to the day some of these features will be implented. :)
 

Chilly

Old Alpha
Joined
Dec 7, 2005
Posts
716
Location
Illinois..Middle of Nowhere
Society
Calypso Chimeras
Avatar Name
Chinchilla Chilly Orbit
I don't know. I suppose I've seen more :bs: in other MA posts:rolleyes: I do find some of the answers interesting but most of the answers weren't very informative (as usual). I'll give MA a C- on this one.


Post 99
Why do some mobs loot a large variety of items while other mobs loot only 1 or 2 items?
Submitted by Chilly

All creatures have different benefits and drawbacks.
I am a little disappointed that this is the best answer that they could come up with. Not..."Some mobs have fewer items drop currently, but may have more items in the future..." Something. Anything. :rolleyes:
 

Cani Ostro

Stalker
Joined
Aug 22, 2006
Posts
2,025
Avatar Name
Cani Monkey Ostro
Items considered obsolete (like old clothes found in the loot) will not be reintroduced.

And no, neither the Imp Mk2 nor Mod FAP is considered obsolete. Just very, very rare.
Is there any ressource for us to gather this information?

Just guessing isn't enough imo when I want to invest into an item. And the market value might vary a lot if the item is obsolete or just rare.

Though we now have two items with a statement to availability, it would be rather benefiting for people to know where to lay there hands or not.
 

Rapido

Prowler
Joined
Aug 3, 2005
Posts
1,085
Location
Strängnäs, Sweden
Society
Rangers
Avatar Name
Rob Rapido Green
Great answers :)

Thank you for this round of Q&A MA, already waiting for the next one :)

Rapido
 

Mel

Alpha
Joined
Dec 1, 2005
Posts
598
Location
USA---Oregon
Society
Hunters Unlimited
Avatar Name
Hormel Mel Jorell
Thanks Marco & Frank...discourse like this benefits not only the player base, but MA also. Just creates alittle more feeling of "partnership" perhaps between players and MA, which is a good thing. I look forward to the future.
 

Sirhc

Elite
Joined
Feb 1, 2005
Posts
4,313
Location
Temple of the Dark parts of the Mind
Society
Freelancer
Avatar Name
Sirhc Xerogs Drakcah
Items considered obsolete (like old clothes found in the loot) will not be reintroduced.

And no, neither the Imp Mk2 nor Mod FAP is considered obsolete. Just very, very rare.
Thanks for the clarification here Marco.

Will Ancient weapons still be a looted item(just more rare than normal versions) or will they be considered just as obsolete as the clothing?

Thanks again,

Chris
 

Aveena

Dominant
Joined
Nov 8, 2005
Posts
397
Location
Oslo, Norway
Society
+Heathens+
Thanks for the answers MA :)

:girl:
 
Top