I think there are some people missing the point of the thread.
PvP is PvP, no rules, etc etc... and I agree. There are no real rules, and sending support cases complaining about being PKed is ludicrous.
A question to those of you on the "anything goes" side (let's call it a question to Tekkie because I know him well enough
) - do you typically PK people while they're on the mob in non-lootable PvP? Do you PK passing miners for no particular reason? Do you stake out revives and kill people multiple times?
My guess (I don't want to speak for you so please tell me if I'm wrong
) is that no, you don't, at least not usually. Maybe you do it now and then when you have some rage to expel
But usually you probably refrain from doing something like that because you think it would be a bit arseholey, right?
On the other side of things, people who get PKed might moan about it a bit, but you don't normally send a support case demanding someone gets banned - again, because that would be a bit arseholey.
I think the question in this thread isn't "What can you and can't you do in PvP?". The question is more like "Where is the line beyond which I will be seen as a bit of a dickhead - or see myself as a bit of a dickhead?"
I think even the most devoted PKers (with a few exceptions perhaps) have some kind of personal honour code - they probably don't have it written down, probably couldn't summarise it to you, and they probably deviate from it now and then, but they have it in their heads.
Another question to those who have "no rules" - do you ever PK your socmates in PvP4 and keep the loot?