Oleg
Mutated
- Joined
- Aug 15, 2006
- Posts
- 19,408
- Location
- Leeds, UK
- Avatar Name
- Oleg Oleg McMullery
Keeping it Top 50 also pushes any reasonably strong mid-level players into more skill level oriented socs if they want to take part in land grab.
Taking Skillin' Villains as an example as they managed to challenge a claim for a while this year, without being eligible to actually win it. It's a nice soc with some experienced players who could very much be in the top 50. If they feel pushed into moving into top 50 socs, the newer players lose the advice and perspective of the more experienced players.
If non-top 50 socs had been able to fight, maybe SV would have got 40 odd people in defending their claim and put up a fight for it. Sure, it's a fight that would have been lost in the end, but it would have been an experience for all involved and there'd have actually been some action.
Everyone should be able to fight for land. In all likelyhood all the winners will come from top 50 socs anyway, but the less skilled socs shouldn't be stopped from making them work for it.
Absolutely right. If SV split into two socs, with say the top 5 forming a new 'SV Elite' soc, we'd be in the Top 50 for sure. Perhaps even our top 10 could get into the 50, but that would be cutting it fine I think.
But that's not an idea we've ever really entertained, because it would dilute the spirit of the society. Most of the newer players appreciate the advice and help they get from the more experienced members, and the fact that there is a mutual respect and friendship across all levels of the society. If we were to remove people like myself, Ari, Twitchie etc, it would radically change the dynamic of the society.
At the same time, I would be sad to no longer be in soc chat with the lower skilled people. They're all my friends, and I like to have them all there together.
Because of that ethic there's absolutely no way that SV will ever get into the Top 50. If I wanted to be in a Top 50 society, I'd have to go elsewhere.
When the Top 50 rule was announced this year I didn't think much of it, thinking it would make no difference to the results. I still don't think a soc outside the top 50 would have any chance of winning a land, so it didn't affect the results in that respect, but it certainly seems to have affected the overall level of engagement.